The Gown Student Newspaper at Queen's University Belfast

NEWS: Vice Chancellor reports to Senate on Russell Group submission

On 22^nd June, QUB Vice Chancellor Peter Gregson provided a brief summary to Senate on the Russell Group submission to the Browne Review. However, Shane Brogan, Students’ Union President at the time, believes that the summary failed to adequately describe what their proposals would mean for students.

BY KERRI-ANNE CAMPBELL

Due to the recent emergency budget, it is inevitable that there will be substantial reductions in university funding from government sources. Shane Brogan stated that Queen’s Students’ Union understands this but he believes the report to be a “systematic attempt to remove the shallow façade of fairness in the current fees system”.

If implemented, the report would see graduates being forced to pay back student loans earlier, the removal of any form of government support for student loans, and students bearing most of the costs of their degree, which the Russell Group set at being between £7,000 and £14,000 depending on the subject.

It would also mean that the protection of the ability to access higher education would be eroded through the abolition of the cap on fees, allowing the most elite and highest quality universities to charge unprecedented fees that put them beyond the reach of many students. This would mean that Queen’s would become like the Ivy League Universities of America.

The report also proposes a number of unfair models to finance student debt involving the Private Sector, many of which transfer substantial risks to students, and again reduce fairness and equality within the higher education sector.

“The proposals are a complete abdication of a university’s responsibility to work in the best interests of its students, and are blatant attempts to channel government money that currently support the poorest and most disadvantaged students, away from them and into university funds,”said Brogan.

He raised a number of comments relating to student fees during Gregson’s report. The university and Russell Group propose a model that is “free at the point of entry”, and where this is technically true in terms of fees, it fails to acknowledge the hidden costs that the university applies throughout a degree.

According to Brogan, the report also failed to address the fact that the average student who started at a NI university in September 2008-2009 can expect to graduate with an average debt of £13,299, a 30% increase on the previous year. This figure is predicted to be more than £15,000 by the time QUB students who started in September 2009 have graduated.

To help pay for the substantial cost of higher education, students in Belfast have one of the highest part-time employment rates during term time of any UK university town.

Russell Group is currently lobbying for a move away from the cap on fees, while at the same time acknowledging the fact that an increase in student fees would inevitably make students reconsider enrolling in university. The Vice Chancellor’s report quotes the initial findings of the Browne Review, which found that students are often deterred by fees.

Vice Chancellor Gregson claimed that a substantial portion of the population supports those that currently benefit from Higher Education and are responsible for contributing. This is recognised by those involved in higher education. However, over the past year all parties, bar that of the relevant minister, have refused to endorse an increase in fees, with both Sinn Fein and SDLP actively committed to their removal.

Brogan said, “The Student’s Union is disappointed that the Report has failed to acknowledge the only fully evaluated proposal put forward to the review by the National Union of Students. The National Union of Students propose a progressive and fairer way of funding student and graduate contributions and protects students from grossly unfair and inevitable debts, by providing a tax on graduates, meaning that the students who benefit most from Higher Education and good quality teaching contribute more over their career. It also proposes a fairer system of students support and ensures that all income streams are fully exploited.”

Brogan went on to say, “It is in no uncertain terms that the proposals of the Russell Group are strongly rejected by the SU and the wider student body at Queen’s, with a record 1,242 voting in a referendum on the issue on 27 May. 1,193, or 96% of them voted against the proposal.”

Tags: fees, Gown, gregson, Kerri-Anne Campbell, newspaper, qub, Queen's, queen's university, shane Brogan, student, students, The Gown

This entry was posted on Saturday, July 10th, 2010 at 1:13 am and is filed under News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.